Comparing car insurance companies is easier when you get expert advice. Whether you need car insurance for a teen driver or you're looking for the best auto-home bundle, we can help.
To make choosing a car insurance company stress-free, our helpful car insurance comparison tool includes the best auto insurance companies in every state. You can quickly compare car insurance quotes and buy a policy online. Enter your ZIP code to get auto insurance quotes and save money today.
Compare quotes in less than 5 minutes
Compare car insurance companies
To choose a car insurance company, you need to learn about the options for buying auto insurance in your area. To make it easier, our experts have gathered details on the top insurers. Learn more about each company and compare auto insurance companies side-by-side easily here.
Company not found
Erie Car Insurance Company
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.7
Average Premium5.0
NAIC0.61
Customer satisfaction4.4
AM BestA+
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.7
Average Premium5.0
NAIC0.61
Customer Satisfaction4.4
AM BestA+
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
Travelers Insurance
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.6
Average Premium4.6
NAIC0.49
Customer satisfaction4.0
AM BestA++
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.6
Average Premium4.6
NAIC0.49
Customer Satisfaction4.0
AM BestA++
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
Nationwide Insurance
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.3
Average Premium4.8
NAIC0.64
Customer satisfaction4.1
AM BestA
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.3
Average Premium4.8
NAIC0.64
Customer Satisfaction4.1
AM BestA
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
AAA The Auto Club Group Car Insurance
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.3
Average Premium4.5
NAIC0.77
Customer satisfaction3.8
AM BestA+
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.3
Average Premium4.5
NAIC0.77
Customer Satisfaction3.8
AM BestA+
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
Geico Insurance
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.2
Average Premium4.0
NAIC0.91
Customer satisfaction4.1
AM BestA++
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.2
Average Premium4.0
NAIC0.91
Customer Satisfaction4.1
AM BestA++
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
Progressive Insurance
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.1
Average Premium3.2
NAIC0.65
Customer satisfaction3.9
AM BestA+
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.1
Average Premium3.2
NAIC0.65
Customer Satisfaction3.9
AM BestA+
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
American Family Insurance
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.0
Average Premium4.2
NAIC1.10
Customer satisfaction4.3
AM BestA
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating4.0
Average Premium4.2
NAIC1.10
Customer Satisfaction4.3
AM BestA
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
Allstate Insurance
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating3.8
Average Premium1.3
NAIC0.65
Customer satisfaction4.0
AM BestA+
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating3.8
Average Premium1.3
NAIC0.65
Customer Satisfaction4.0
AM BestA+
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
Farmers Insurance
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating3.7
Average Premium1.8
NAIC0.80
Customer satisfaction4.1
AM BestA
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating3.7
Average Premium1.8
NAIC0.80
Customer Satisfaction4.1
AM BestA
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
Mercury Insurance
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating3.6
Average Premium2.0
NAIC0.84
Customer satisfaction4.0
AM BestA
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating3.6
Average Premium2.0
NAIC0.84
Customer Satisfaction4.0
AM BestA
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
CSAA Insurance Group
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating3.5
Average Premium1.0
NAIC0.75
Customer satisfaction4.1
AM BestA
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating3.5
Average Premium1.0
NAIC0.75
Customer Satisfaction4.1
AM BestA
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
AAA (Automobile Club of Southern California) Insurance Review
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating3.3
Average Premium2.1
NAIC2.21
Customer satisfaction4.2
AM BestA-
How we weigh our score
Overall Rating3.3
Average Premium2.1
NAIC2.21
Customer Satisfaction4.2
AM BestA-
Add to Compare
Show score details
Claims Processing
Customer Service
Value for Price
Website & Apps
21st Century Insurance
Dairyland Auto Insurance
Elephant Insurance
Infinity Auto Insurance Company
Liberty Mutual Insurance
MetLife Auto Insurance
Metromile Insurance
QBE Insurance
Safeco Insurance
The General Insurance
The Hartford Insurance
USAA Car Insurance Company
Data updated in 2024
Not sure which company is right for you? Compare car insurance companies side by side here.
VS
Mercury Insurance
Progressive Insurance
VS
Mercury Insurance
Travelers Insurance
VS
Nationwide Insurance
Erie Car Insurance Company
VS
Nationwide Insurance
Progressive Insurance
VS
Progressive Insurance
American Family Insurance
VS
Progressive Insurance
Erie Car Insurance Company
VS
Progressive Insurance
Farmers Insurance
VS
State Farm
American Family Insurance
VS
State Farm
Mercury Insurance
VS
Travelers Insurance
Progressive Insurance
Auto insurance FAQ
How do I choose the best car insurance company?
To find the best car insurance company for you, start with our top-rated companies. It's important to compare car insurance companies on more than just rates; compare each company's reputation for customer service, claims satisfaction and financial stability so you can be confident in your choice.
How much car insurance do I need?
You have to carry at least the minimum coverage required in your state. However, these limits are low and won't protect you in even a moderately serious accident. You also have to carry comprehensive and collision if you have a loan or lease; it's a good idea either way if you can't afford to repair or replace your car out of pocket. A car insurance coverage calculator makes it easy to find the right coverage.
What car insurance discounts should I look for?
Look for discounts that fit your situation. If you don't drive much, ask about low mileage discounts. If you have a teen driver, ask about driver education discounts. Some of the most common auto insurance discounts include:
- Bundling discount (multi-policy)
- Safe driving discount
- Loyalty discount
- Accident-free discount
- Paperless discount
- Good student
Compare Companies
Compare companies to find the best fit for you!
All you need to do is find companies you like and click ,"Add to Compare."
When you’re ready to review, click the compare button that appears in this menu.
